Federated and decentralized machine learning offer the potential to extract valuable healthcare insights from siloed data without requiring the centralization of sensitive patient records, addressing long-standing privacy and governance challenges. This critical review assesses federated learning in healthcare through three lenses: privacy-preserving technologies, incentive mechanisms, and regulatory compliance frameworks. It examines whether the claims in existing literature are substantiated by real-world evidence from healthcare settings. The review reveals considerable enthusiasm for federated learning but identifies gaps, including incomplete implementation of privacy technologies, theoretical incentive mechanisms, and regulatory compliance often assumed but not validated. Additionally, real-world deployments are limited in scale and duration. The review concludes that the gap between federated learning's theoretical potential and clinical application remains significant, with overstated privacy claims and a lack of established frameworks for incentives and compliance.
Clinical Intelligence Research Press